NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Wash Sales

How the Wash Sale Rule Reaches Across a Household

A purchase by a spouse, an IRA or a controlled entity can disallow a loss realized in a tax-aware long/short account.

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, realizes losses as it trades on return forecasts for pre-tax alpha and diversification. A realized loss is deductible only when the tax rules allow it. The wash sale rule is the most common reason a loss is disallowed. The rule reaches a spouse's accounts, IRAs and entities the investor controls. A manager sees only the account it manages.

The wash sale window and the accounts it reaches

A purchase of substantially identical stock in any of these accounts inside the window can disallow the loss.

  • The same account
  • Another taxable account
  • A spouse's account
  • A controlled corporation
  • An IRA or Roth IRA

Illustration of the general rule in section 1091 of the Internal Revenue Code. How it applies to a given household is a question for the investor's tax adviser.

The rule

Section 1091 of the Internal Revenue Code disallows a loss on a sale of stock or securities when the taxpayer acquires substantially identical stock or securities within 30 days before or after the sale. The window is 61 days including the sale date. A contract or option to acquire the stock within that window also counts.

A disallowed loss is usually deferred. The disallowed amount is added to the basis of the replacement shares (section 1091(d)). The holding period of the old shares carries over (section 1223(3)). The loss is recognized when the replacement shares are later sold. The deferral has a cost in an active strategy. A loss intended for the current year may move to a later year. The household may also continue to hold the position the loss came from.

Partial overlaps are matched share for share. Where fewer shares are bought than sold, only the matching number of sold shares loses its deduction (Treas. Reg. section 1.1091-1(c)). The rule also covers short positions. Section 1091(e) applies similar rules to a loss on closing a short sale. The trigger is a sale of substantially identical stock, or a new short sale of it, within 30 days before or after the closing.

"Substantially identical" has no precise definition. IRS Publication 550 says the answer depends on all the facts and circumstances. It adds that stock of one corporation ordinarily is not substantially identical to stock of another.

Spouses and controlled entities

The statute refers to "the taxpayer" and does not mention family members. The IRS applies it more broadly. Publication 550 states that a sale by one spouse and a purchase of substantially identical stock by the other is a wash sale. It says the same of a purchase by a corporation the seller controls.

A 1933 Board of Tax Appeals case, Security First National Bank of Los Angeles, applied similar reasoning. A taxpayer sold bonds to a corporation he wholly owned. The same day, the corporation passed them to a trust he controlled. The Board disallowed the loss because the taxpayer still controlled the property. The IRS relied on the same case in its 2008 ruling on retirement accounts. Trusts, family entities and other accounts an investor directs can raise the same question. The reach of the rule in a given structure depends on the facts and should be reviewed with a tax adviser.

Which purchases can disallow a loss

Purchase made inGeneral treatmentSource
The same accountA wash sale, adjusted on the account's Form 1099-BIRC 1091 and Treas. Reg. 1.6045-1
Another taxable accountA wash sale the investor reports on Form 8949IRC 1091
A spouse's accountTreated by the IRS as a wash saleIRS Publication 550
A controlled corporationTreated by the IRS as a wash saleIRS Publication 550
An IRA or Roth IRALoss disallowed and generally not recoveredRevenue Ruling 2008-5

Retirement accounts

Revenue Ruling 2008-5 addressed an investor who sold stock at a loss and caused an IRA to buy the same stock the next day. The IRS held that the loss is disallowed under section 1091. The same holding applies to a Roth IRA. The ruling also held that the investor's basis in the IRA is not increased by the disallowed amount.

In a taxable account a disallowed loss is added to the basis of the replacement shares and recognized later. The ruling allows no such basis adjustment inside an IRA. A loss disallowed by an IRA purchase is generally not recovered.

The ruling addresses IRAs and Roth IRAs. Its reasoning rests on the investor's control over the purchase. Investors who direct trades in other retirement accounts should ask their tax adviser how it applies to them.

The limits of the manager's view

NinePointTwo has no access to a client's other accounts. Accounts are held in the client's name at Interactive Brokers, and NinePointTwo manages the strategy in that account only. It cannot see trades by a spouse, an IRA, a trust or another manager.

The custodian's reporting has the same limit. Treasury regulations require a broker to apply the wash sale rule in one case (Treas. Reg. section 1.6045-1(d)(6)(iii)(A)). Both the sale and the purchase must be covered securities with the same CUSIP number in the same account. A wash sale created by a purchase in another account is generally not shown as an adjustment on the account's Form 1099-B. The investor reports it on Form 8949 with adjustment code W.

Shorting a stock the investor already holds at a gain elsewhere can be treated as a constructive sale of that holding under section 1259. The gain would be recognized as though the holding had been sold. The statute extends this to transactions by a related person entered into to avoid the rule.

Information for the manager

Avoiding these outcomes requires coordination at onboarding and updates afterward. NinePointTwo restricts the securities a client identifies, which helps avoid wash sales and constructive sales. Restrictions cannot prevent them in all cases. The most useful information includes the following.

  • Holdings and recurring purchases in the investor's other taxable accounts, including those managed by other firms.
  • A spouse's accounts.
  • IRAs, Roth IRAs and other retirement accounts the investor directs.
  • Accounts of trusts, family partnerships and corporations the investor controls.
  • Dividend reinvestment plans.
  • Employer stock purchase plans and planned purchases of individual stocks.
  • Any other account running a tax-loss harvesting program. Two harvesting programs can trigger wash sales against each other.

Each restricted name reduces the set of stocks the optimizer can trade. The cost is modest for a short list and grows with a longer one. A restriction can also remove a stock the return model would have held or shorted. Restrictions known in advance can be incorporated with less effect on the forecasts.

Common questions

Does the wash sale rule apply across different accounts?

Yes. Section 1091 applies to the taxpayer as a whole. A purchase of substantially identical stock in any account the taxpayer owns, within 30 days before or after a loss sale, can disallow the loss.

Does a spouse's purchase trigger a wash sale?

IRS Publication 550 states that it does. A sale by one spouse followed by a purchase of substantially identical stock by the other spouse within the window is treated as a wash sale. The publication says the same of a purchase by a corporation the seller controls.

What happens when an IRA buys the stock?

Under Revenue Ruling 2008-5, the loss on the sale is disallowed. The investor's basis in the IRA or Roth IRA is not increased by the disallowed amount, so the loss is generally not recovered later.

Does the custodian's Form 1099-B catch every wash sale?

No. Brokers are required to adjust for wash sales only when the sale and purchase involve the same security in the same account. The investor reports wash sales caused by other accounts on Form 8949 with adjustment code W.

What should an investor tell NinePointTwo?

Holdings and planned purchases in other accounts, including a spouse's accounts, IRAs, accounts of entities the investor controls, dividend reinvestment plans and other tax-loss harvesting programs. NinePointTwo restricts those securities in the account, which helps avoid wash sales and constructive sales.

More on tax-aware long/short

Funding in kind

How existing stocks and funds transfer into a long/short account without a sale, and which holdings generally cannot.

Read the explainer

Tax time

The longer Form 1099, short-sale holding periods, investment interest and the records a tax preparer needs.

Read the explainer

Versus direct indexing

How tax-aware long/short and direct indexing realize losses, and why harvesting in a long-only portfolio slows.

Compare with direct indexing

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC ("NinePointTwo") for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as tax, legal, or investment advice, or as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment service. It contains no actual, hypothetical, simulated, or back-tested performance information. The description of federal tax rules herein is general, is based on the Internal Revenue Code, Treasury regulations, and Internal Revenue Service guidance as of the date of publication, does not address state or local tax, and is subject to change, possibly with retroactive effect. The application of these rules depends on each taxpayer's particular facts, and investors should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. NinePointTwo has no access to accounts it does not manage, and wash sales and constructive sales caused by activity in those accounts may reduce or defer the tax benefits of its strategies; its restriction of identified securities may help avoid, but cannot prevent in all cases, such outcomes. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve substantial risks, including, without limitation, the risks of leverage, short selling, financing and borrowing costs, model risk, and returns that may differ materially from those of any benchmark. Tax-loss harvesting defers rather than eliminates tax. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Further information about NinePointTwo, including its fees and conflicts of interest, is set forth in its Form ADV Part 2A. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.