NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Funding in Kind

Funding a Tax-Aware Long/Short Account In Kind

How existing stocks and funds transfer into a tax-aware long/short account without a sale.

Existing stocks and funds can generally transfer into a tax-aware long/short account in kind. The transfer realizes no gain. The long/short book is then built around the transferred holdings and managed for pre-tax alpha and diversification. Appreciated positions can remain in the account while the book is built.

Three kinds of legacy holding

The transfer of existing holdings into a long/short account

Existing holdings

Held at another firm or custodian

Transfer in kind. Cost basis and holding periods carry over.

Long/short account

The models then rank each holding

  1. A weak forecast and a loss

    The position is generally sold early. The sale realizes a loss and removes a position the models do not favor.

  2. A strong forecast

    The position is generally kept. Its embedded gain stays deferred.

  3. A weak forecast and a large gain

    The optimizer weighs the forecast against the tax cost. Other positions can reduce the unwanted exposure.

Illustration of the general sequence. Which holdings can transfer depends on the custodian, and each sale decision depends on the forecast and the tax cost at the time.

Transfers in kind

A gain is taxed on a sale or other disposition. A transfer between two accounts of the same owner is neither. The shares keep their cost basis and acquisition dates.

The delivering broker sends the receiving broker a transfer statement within 15 days of settlement. The statement lists the adjusted basis and acquisition date of each covered lot. The investor supplies the basis of older, uncovered lots from personal records. Holding periods carry over. A lot held more than one year remains long-term.

An account funded with stock begins with embedded gains. A cash account begins with none. The investment program is the same in both.

Legacy holdings in the optimization

Each legacy holding enters the portfolio optimization like any other position. The alpha model assigns it an expected return. NinePointTwo's in-house risk model measures its contribution to risk, including its sector, style and stock-specific exposures. The tax cost of selling each lot is a third input.

The three inputs lead to different treatment for different holdings. A stock the models rate poorly that carries a large gain is the difficult case. A sale realizes the gain. Keeping the stock leaves unwanted risk in the portfolio.

The strategy does not short the same stock to hedge the holding. A short sale of the same or substantially identical stock against an appreciated long position can be treated as a constructive sale, which realizes the gain. Other positions selected through the risk model can reduce the exposure.

The long/short book realizes losses as it trades on its forecasts. Those losses can defer gains as legacy positions are sold. The pace depends on markets, leverage and the forecasts.

Concentrated, low-basis positions

A single stock with a large embedded gain is the most common reason to fund in kind. Prism Diversify is the approach within Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, designed for this case. It applies the same long/short process to reducing a concentrated, low-basis position over time. Prism Diversify seeks to broaden the portfolio while managing the tax drag of realizing the embedded gain, with the potential for additional alpha along the way.

The expected path of the sell-down is typically modeled with the client before implementation. A sell-down takes several years. Neither the pace nor the losses are guaranteed. Higher leverage generally realizes losses faster and diversifies the position sooner. It also carries more tracking error. Prism configurations range from 130/30 to 300/200.

Some concentrated positions carry restrictions on sale. Shares held by an officer, director or other affiliate may be subject to Rule 144 resale conditions, company trading windows or pre-clearance. Restricted shares may need a legend removed before they can be sold.

Eligible holdings

Prism accounts are held at Interactive Brokers. The custodian's eligibility rules determine what can transfer in kind. U.S.-listed common stocks, American depositary receipts and exchange-traded funds generally transfer.

A mutual fund transfers only when the receiving custodian offers it. Some share classes can be held only at the sponsoring firm. Those funds generally have to be sold at the delivering firm or exchanged into a share class the receiving custodian can hold. A sale realizes the fund's embedded gain or loss.

Unvested equity awards and shares in private companies are not transferable brokerage positions. A transfer from an IRA or other retirement account to a taxable account is treated as a distribution. The delivering broker often sells fractional shares as part of the transfer.

Funds that transfer can be held in the account. The risk model measures a fund's contribution to risk as it does for any position. A fund becomes a candidate for sale when realized losses can defer its gain and the models prefer individual stocks.

Holdings that transfer in kind

Generally transfers in kind

U.S.-listed common stocks

American depositary receipts

Exchange-traded funds

Mutual funds the custodian offers

Generally cannot

Fund share classes held only at their sponsor

Unvested equity awards

Shares in private companies

Assets inside an IRA or other retirement account

Holdings in other accounts

A transfer in kind moves only the shares in the transferring account. The wash sale rule applies across all of an investor's accounts, including IRAs. The constructive sale rule also reaches holdings in other accounts. A purchase in another account within 30 days before or after a loss sale can disallow the loss. NinePointTwo restricts securities the client holds elsewhere to help avoid both. The investor's other managers need to know those restrictions as well.

Common questions

Can a tax-aware long/short account be funded with existing stock?

Generally yes. Shares transfer in kind and the transfer realizes no gain. Each lot keeps its cost basis and acquisition date. The long/short book is built around the holdings.

Does an investor have to sell existing holdings before starting Prism tax-aware long/short?

No. Appreciated positions can remain while the long/short book is built around them. The models weigh each position's forecast against the tax cost of selling it.

Can mutual funds be transferred into the account?

A fund transfers only when the custodian offers it. A share class held only at its sponsor generally has to be sold or exchanged first, and that sale realizes any embedded gain or loss.

How is a concentrated, low-basis stock position handled?

Prism Diversify sells the position down over time. Losses realized by the long/short book can defer the gains. A sell-down takes several years, fewer at higher leverage. The pace and the losses are not guaranteed.

Can the account short the same stock it received to hedge it?

Generally no. Shorting the same or substantially identical stock against an appreciated position can be a constructive sale, which realizes the gain. Any hedging comes from other positions.

More on tax-aware long/short

Three routes for concentrated stock

Section 351 conversions, exchange funds, and tax-aware long/short accounts compared for low-basis holdings.

Compare the three routes

Wash sales across a household

How purchases by a spouse, an IRA, or a controlled entity can disallow a loss realized in a long/short account.

Read the explainer

Leaving the strategy

What happens to deferred gains when an investor lowers leverage, moves to direct indexing, or transfers the account.

Read the explainer

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, legal or accounting advice, or as an offer or solicitation with respect to any security or strategy. It contains no hypothetical, simulated or actual performance information. The tax and custody treatment described herein is general in nature, is based on federal law and custodial practice as understood at the date of publication, is subject to change, and may not apply to any particular investor or security. Each investor should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve leverage and short selling, which can magnify losses, including losses in excess of the amount initially invested in a given position, and involve financing, borrowing and trading costs, margin calls and benchmark deviation. The pace of any sell-down and the amount of any realized losses are not guaranteed, there can be no assurance that any strategy will achieve its objectives or generate pre-tax alpha, and an investor may lose money. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.