NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Versus Direct Indexing

Tax-Aware Long/Short vs. Direct Indexing

Both approaches hold individual stocks in an account in the investor's name and realize losses for tax purposes.They differ in the source of pre-tax return, the duration of loss realization, and the risks each one carries.

How the two approaches differ

Direct indexing holds the stocks of an index directly in a separately managed account. It sells holdings that fall below cost to realize tax losses and buys similar stocks in their place. The portfolio continues to track the index.

Tax-aware long/short uses the same kind of account and adds long and short positions selected on return forecasts. The added positions seek pre-tax alpha and diversification. They also give the account more positions that can be closed at a loss. A short position can realize a loss when its stock rises.

Loss harvesting in direct indexing generally slows as the portfolio appreciates. A long/short book is designed to realize losses over a longer period. It also carries leverage, short-selling risk, financing costs, and more tracking error than an index portfolio.

Pre-tax alpha in each approach

A tax-aware long/short account is an active investment program first. Its losses arise while the program pursues its expected return.

Without that expected return the account carries leverage, costs, and benchmark deviation with nothing to cover them.

Deviation that carries a forecast

Both approaches deviate from their benchmark. In direct indexing the deviation is a side effect of harvesting and carries no return forecast. The deviation of a long/short book is intended. The book is long the stocks its models rate highest and short those they rate lowest.

Acting on negative views

A long-only portfolio can act on a negative view only by underweighting a stock, up to its index weight. A short book can act on the same view more fully. That was the original case for 130/30 strategies, which predates their use for tax management.

Alpha and the tax benefit together

Higher returns build embedded gains, which can slow harvesting. Alpha also grows the account. Restoring target leverage then opens new positions with no embedded gain. Over longer horizons the second effect can outweigh the first.

The test we apply to our own strategy is the pre-tax one. A tax-aware strategy should be one an investor would want to hold with no tax benefit at all.

How each approach invests and realizes losses

Tax-aware long/short

Source of return

Market exposure plus return forecasts on both sides

Positions

Long and short, from 130/30 to 300/200

Market exposure

About $100 for each $100 invested

Where losses come from

Long positions that fall and short positions that rise

A tax-aware long/short account keeps the market exposure and adds long and short positions of equal size. At 130/30, each $100 invested supports $130 of long positions and $30 of short positions. Net market exposure stays near $100. Higher configurations add more of both.

A short position loses value when its stock rises. Closing it then realizes a loss. Individual stocks diverge even when the market moves in one direction. At any time some long positions and some short positions show losses. The account can realize losses in rising and falling markets.

As forecasts change, the models replace positions. New positions enter at current prices.

Direct indexing

Source of return

The index, held close to its weights

Positions

Long only, in the stocks of a chosen index

Market exposure

About $100 for each $100 invested

Where losses come from

Holdings that fall below their purchase price

A direct indexing account buys most or all of the stocks in an index, weighted to track it closely. Through the year, some holdings fall below the price paid for them. The manager sells those lots to realize the loss and buys stocks with similar characteristics in their place.

The wash sale rule disallows a loss when the investor buys a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale. The replacements are different stocks selected to keep the portfolio close to the index.

The opportunity is largest in the first years. In a rising market, most holdings move above their cost and stay there. Keeping the portfolio close to the index may then require selling them at a gain. New cash and market declines renew the opportunity temporarily.

How Prism tax-aware long/short pursues alpha and manages taxes

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, runs on the same alpha models as the firm's tax-agnostic long/short equity strategies. Positions generally follow those forecasts, because the strategy seeks pre-tax alpha with low correlation to the market.

Prism manages taxes within the limits of its return model. Gains are typically deferred and losses realized, and the losses arise within the investment process.

How the two approaches compare

The table compares Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, with a typical direct indexing account. Terms vary by provider and by account.

Prism Tax-Aware Long/ShortDirect Indexing
Source of pre-tax returnMarket exposure plus a long/short alpha overlayMarket exposure, held close to the index
Use of negative viewsA short book holds the stocks the models expect to underperformUnderweighting only, down to zero
Positions heldLong and short positions in individual stocksLong positions in individual stocks
Market exposureAbout 100% net, with gross exposure of 160% at 130/30 and 500% at 300/200About 100%, with no leverage
Loss harvesting as markets riseDesigned to continue. Short positions can realize losses as stocks rise.Generally slows as holdings appreciate
Tracking errorHigher, rising with leverageLow by design
FinancingMargin interest on the added long positions and fees to borrow the stocks sold shortNone
Main risksMarket risk, leverage, short selling, and the accuracy of the manager's forecastsMarket risk and the index's own concentration
Account and tax reportingSeparately managed account in the client's name, with a longer standard 1099Separately managed account in the client's name, with a standard 1099
Typical minimumsAccounts generally from $1 millionWidely available at lower minimums
ExitNo lockup. Closing the account realizes its embedded gains and losses, or it can move to long-only direct indexing.No lockup. Selling the holdings realizes their embedded gains.

Source of pre-tax return

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Market exposure plus a long/short alpha overlay

Direct Indexing

Market exposure, held close to the index

Use of negative views

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

A short book holds the stocks the models expect to underperform

Direct Indexing

Underweighting only, down to zero

Positions held

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Long and short positions in individual stocks

Direct Indexing

Long positions in individual stocks

Market exposure

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

About 100% net, with gross exposure of 160% at 130/30 and 500% at 300/200

Direct Indexing

About 100%, with no leverage

Loss harvesting as markets rise

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Designed to continue. Short positions can realize losses as stocks rise.

Direct Indexing

Generally slows as holdings appreciate

Tracking error

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Higher, rising with leverage

Direct Indexing

Low by design

Financing

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Margin interest on the added long positions and fees to borrow the stocks sold short

Direct Indexing

None

Main risks

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Market risk, leverage, short selling, and the accuracy of the manager's forecasts

Direct Indexing

Market risk and the index's own concentration

Account and tax reporting

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Separately managed account in the client's name, with a longer standard 1099

Direct Indexing

Separately managed account in the client's name, with a standard 1099

Typical minimums

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Accounts generally from $1 million

Direct Indexing

Widely available at lower minimums

Exit

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

No lockup. Closing the account realizes its embedded gains and losses, or it can move to long-only direct indexing.

Direct Indexing

No lockup. Selling the holdings realizes their embedded gains.

The added costs and risks of the long/short book

The additional losses come with costs and risks a long-only index portfolio does not carry. The long/short book's pre-tax alpha has to cover those costs before the tax benefit adds anything.

  • Leverage and financing

    Long positions above 100% of the account are financed. The account pays margin interest and fees to borrow the stocks it sells short. Both costs rise with the configuration.

  • Short-selling risk

    A short position loses money when its stock rises, and that loss has no fixed limit. Lenders can recall borrowed shares. Heavily shorted stocks can rise sharply in a short squeeze.

  • Tracking error and model risk

    Returns can differ from the benchmark by a wide margin. The long/short book depends on the manager's return forecasts, which can be wrong for long periods.

Both approaches defer tax. The gains embedded in the portfolio are taxed when its positions are eventually sold.

Which investors each approach suits

The long/short structure generally offers pre-tax alpha potential and more realized losses over a longer period. It suits a taxable investor who wants an active return source alongside market exposure and can carry leverage. Direct indexing is the simpler choice where low tracking error matters most.

Direct indexing

  • Investors who want index exposure with low tracking error
  • Accounts that receive new cash regularly, which renews the harvesting
  • Accounts below the minimums of long/short strategies
  • Investors who prefer to avoid leverage and short selling

Tax-aware long/short

  • Investors who want pre-tax alpha and diversification from a long/short book
  • Investors expecting large gains from a business sale, carried interest, or a concentrated position
  • Investors whose direct indexing portfolio holds large embedded gains
  • Investors who accept leverage, short selling, and higher tracking error

The two approaches can be combined. Appreciated holdings from an existing direct indexing portfolio may remain while the long/short book seeks pre-tax alpha and realizes losses. An investor leaving Prism tax-aware long/short can move to long-only direct indexing. That transition may be managed without a tax impact.

Common questions

What is the difference between direct indexing and tax-aware long/short?

Direct indexing holds the stocks of an index long only and sells those that fall below cost to realize tax losses. Tax-aware long/short keeps the same market exposure and adds long and short positions chosen by return forecasts. The short positions let the account realize losses when stocks rise, and the long/short book seeks pre-tax alpha. The added positions bring leverage, short-selling risk, financing costs, and higher tracking error.

What is pre-tax alpha in a tax-aware long/short strategy?

Pre-tax alpha is the return a strategy seeks above its benchmark before any tax effect. In tax-aware long/short it comes from the long/short book, which holds stocks the manager's models expect to outperform and shorts those they expect to underperform. The alpha has to cover the strategy's higher fees, financing, and trading costs before the tax benefit adds anything. A strategy that depends on its tax benefit alone carries leverage and benchmark risk with no expected return behind them.

Does more alpha mean fewer losses to realize?

Not necessarily. Embedded gains from higher returns can slow harvesting. Alpha also grows the base that losses are drawn from. Keeping leverage on target as the account grows opens new long and short positions with no embedded gain. In a long/short extension these two effects can outweigh the slower harvesting over longer horizons, so alpha and the tax benefit may reinforce each other.

Why does tax-loss harvesting in direct indexing slow down?

A long-only portfolio can only realize a loss on a holding that trades below its cost. Markets rise more often than they fall, so most holdings move above cost over time. Each harvest also lowers the cost basis of the replacement position. After several years the portfolio holds mostly embedded gains and few losses to realize. New cash contributions and market declines renew the opportunity for a while.

How does a short position realize a tax loss?

A short sale sells borrowed shares and buys them back later. When the stock rises, buying the shares back costs more than the sale brought in, and closing the position realizes that difference as a loss. In a rising market some short positions rise above their sale price, which gives a long/short account losses to realize when a long-only account has few.

Is tax-aware long/short riskier than direct indexing?

It carries risks that direct indexing does not. Leverage magnifies gains and losses. Short positions can lose more than their initial value, and borrowed shares can be recalled. Returns can differ widely from the benchmark, and the long/short book depends on the accuracy of the manager's forecasts. Net market exposure stays close to that of an index portfolio.

Can a direct indexing portfolio move into tax-aware long/short?

Yes. The existing holdings do not need to be sold first. Appreciated positions can stay in place while the long/short book is built around them. Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, works with cash or any existing portfolio.

Does either of these approaches eliminate capital gains tax?

No. Both defer it. Realized losses can be applied against gains, and the account keeps a lower cost basis in return. The deferred tax comes due when the positions are sold. A portfolio that defers taxes compounds on a larger base in the meantime.

How do the costs compare?

Tax-aware long/short generally costs more than direct indexing. Management fees are typically higher, and the account also pays margin interest and fees to borrow the stocks it sells short. The strategy's pre-tax alpha has to cover those costs. Fee terms for Prism tax-aware long/short are set out in NinePointTwo's Form ADV.

How does the wash sale rule apply to these strategies?

The wash sale rule disallows a loss when a substantially identical security is bought within 30 days before or after the sale. It applies across all of an investor's accounts. Both approaches avoid repurchasing the same stock inside that window. The manager needs to know about holdings elsewhere to coordinate around them.

More on tax-aware long/short

The strategy

How tax-aware long/short works, the configurations from 130/30 to 300/200, and the investors it is designed for.

Read about the strategy

The three approaches

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, in three approaches for alpha, concentrated stock, and an existing portfolio.

Explore the approaches

The illustration tool

A hypothetical comparison of selling a concentrated position today with deferring the gain through tax-aware long/short.

Model a position

The provider comparison

Tax-aware long/short providers compared on minimums, fees, leverage, custody, and access, with dated sources.

Compare the providers

Versus exchange funds

How tax-aware long/short and exchange funds diversify a concentrated position, and the tradeoffs of each.

Compare with exchange funds

Three routes for concentrated stock

Section 351 conversions, exchange funds, and tax-aware long/short accounts compared for low-basis holdings.

Compare the three routes

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This page is a general comparison of two investment approaches and is provided for informational purposes only. It describes typical structures rather than any specific provider, and terms vary. Nothing herein should be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing involves substantial risk, including the possible loss of principal. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve unique risks, including short selling and leverage, and may not be suitable for all investors. Tax-loss harvesting defers tax and does not eliminate it. The effectiveness of tax management strategies depends on individual taxpayer circumstances and may vary. Past performance is not indicative of future results. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.