NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Tax Time

A Long/Short Account at Tax Time

The forms, the short-sale rules and the deductions a tax-aware long/short account brings.

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, trades for pre-tax alpha and diversification. Each trade is reported for tax purposes. The tax statement is longer than a long-only account's. Most tax software imports it automatically. An investor should confirm the treatment of their own return with a tax professional.

The sequence of tax documents for a long/short account
  1. By February 15

    The composite Form 1099 arrives

    Form 1099-B lists sales and closed short sales. Forms 1099-DIV and 1099-INT report dividends and interest.

  2. After the first statement

    Corrections can follow

    An issuer can reclassify a distribution after year end. The custodian then sends a corrected statement.

  3. At filing

    The investor reports

    Sales go on Form 8949 and Schedule D. Form 4952 computes the investment interest deduction.

Illustration of the usual sequence. A tax preparer decides how each item is reported on a given return.

The composite Form 1099 statement

The custodian, Interactive Brokers for NinePointTwo accounts, issues a composite tax statement in the client's name. It combines several forms in one document.

A long/short account can produce many pages of Form 1099-B.

Brokers must furnish the composite statement by February 15 under section 6045(b). Corrected statements can follow, for example when an issuer reclassifies a distribution after year end. Most tax software and preparers import the data directly. Length alone adds little work.

Forms in a long/short tax return

FormWhat it reports
Form 1099-BEach sale and closed short sale, with proceeds, cost basis and gain or loss
Form 1099-DIVDividends received on long positions
Form 1099-INTInterest income the account earned
Form 8949 and Schedule DWhere the investor reports sales, with any adjustments such as wash sales
Form 4952The investment interest deduction and any amount carried forward

Form 8949 and Schedule D

Sales from Form 1099-B flow to Form 8949, sorted into short-term and long-term parts, and the totals carry to Schedule D. The Form 8949 instructions allow a shortcut. Transactions whose basis was reported to the IRS, with no adjustments, can be totaled directly on Schedule D. Any transaction that needs an adjustment goes on Form 8949 line by line.

Wash sales are the most common adjustment. The custodian is required to adjust for wash sales only when the sale and the repurchase involve the same security in the same account. The investor reports a wash sale caused by a purchase in another account, by a spouse or by an IRA. It is entered on Form 8949 with code W in column (f) and the disallowed amount in column (g).

Capital losses beyond capital gains can be deducted against ordinary income up to $3,000 a year (section 1211(b)). The limit is $1,500 for a married person filing separately. The unused loss carries forward to later years and keeps its short-term or long-term character (section 1212(b)). The custodian does not report the carryforward. The investor or preparer tracks it from year to year.

Short sales and holding periods

A short sale realizes no gain or loss when the stock is sold. The gain or loss is generally recognized when the position is closed by delivering shares to the lender. The custodian reports the closing in that year's Form 1099-B.

The character of the gain or loss follows the shares delivered to close. Publication 550 states that the holding period generally depends on how long the investor held those shares. A short position is usually closed with shares bought that day. Its gain or loss is generally short-term regardless of how long the position was open.

Section 1233 adds two special rules. They generally apply when the investor holds substantially identical stock at the time of the short sale. A gain on closing the short is short-term when that stock had been held for one year or less. The holding period of that stock then restarts. A loss on closing the short is long-term when that stock had been held for more than one year. A short sale against an appreciated holding can also be a constructive sale under section 1259, which recognizes the gain immediately.

Short-term gains are taxed at ordinary rates and long-term gains at lower rates. The optimizer weighs that difference alongside the return forecasts. It generally realizes losses and defers gains within the limits the return models set.

Investment interest

When a stock the account has sold short pays a dividend, the account pays the lender an equal amount. Section 263(h) governs that payment. The payment is not deductible when the short is closed within 45 days. The period is one year for an extraordinary dividend. An exception to the 45-day rule allows a deduction up to the interest the account earned on that short's collateral. The amount is added to the basis of the shares used to close the short instead. Payments on shorts held open longer are generally deductible as investment interest on Schedule A, by investors who itemize.

Margin interest on the financed long positions is also investment interest. Section 163(d) limits the deduction to net investment income, and Form 4952 computes the limit. Interest and non-qualified dividends count as investment income. Qualified dividends and net capital gain count only when the investor elects to include them. The election gives up the lower tax rate on the amount included. Disallowed interest carries forward to the next year (section 163(d)(2)).

The fee for borrowing stock to sell short is a separate cost. Its tax treatment depends on how it is characterized and should be reviewed with a preparer.

Margin interest, dividend payments on shorts and borrow fees are paid in cash. Pre-tax alpha has to cover them. A deduction may lower their after-tax cost.

Records for the tax preparer

Corrected statements can arrive after the first filing deadline. Some investors with active accounts routinely file an extension, which gives the preparer time to work from final figures.

A preparer working on a long/short account generally needs the following.

Records by source

From the custodian

The composite Form 1099 and any corrections

Year-end statements of margin interest and payments in lieu

Basis and dates for stock transferred in kind

From the investor

A list of other accounts, including a spouse's and IRAs

Last year's loss and investment interest carryovers

The election on qualified dividends and net capital gain

Common questions

What tax forms does a tax-aware long/short account produce?

The custodian issues a composite Form 1099. It generally includes Form 1099-B for sales and closed short sales, Form 1099-DIV for dividends and Form 1099-INT for interest. The 1099-B runs longer than in a long-only account because the strategy trades more often.

Are gains on short sales short-term or long-term?

Generally short-term. Under Publication 550, the holding period of a short sale depends on the shares delivered to close it, which are usually bought the same day. Section 1233 sets special rules when the investor holds substantially identical stock at the time of the short sale.

Are payments in lieu of dividends deductible?

Under section 263(h), they are not deductible when the short sale is closed within 45 days, and the payment is added to the basis of the shares used to close it. A deduction is allowed up to the interest earned on that short's collateral. Payments on shorts held open longer are generally deductible as investment interest by investors who itemize, subject to the net investment income limit on Form 4952.

Is margin interest deductible?

Margin interest on investment positions is generally investment interest under section 163(d). The deduction is limited to net investment income, and disallowed interest carries forward to the next year. Qualified dividends and net capital gain count as investment income only by election, which gives up their lower tax rate on the amount elected.

Does the custodian's Form 1099-B report every wash sale?

No. The custodian is required to adjust only for wash sales within the same account involving the same security. Wash sales caused by other accounts are reported by the investor on Form 8949 with code W.

More on tax-aware long/short

Wash sales across a household

How purchases by a spouse, an IRA, or a controlled entity can disallow a loss realized in a long/short account.

Read the explainer

The cost of shorting

Borrow fees, financing, payments in lieu of dividends and trading costs, which pre-tax alpha has to cover.

Read the explainer

Where deferred gains end

How a deferred gain ends in a sale, a move to long-only, a bequest, a charitable gift or a gift to family.

Read the explainer

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC ("NinePointTwo") for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as tax, legal, or investment advice, or as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment service. It contains no actual, hypothetical, simulated, or back-tested performance information. The description of federal tax reporting and tax rules herein is general, is based on the Internal Revenue Code, Treasury regulations, and Internal Revenue Service forms, instructions, and publications as of the date of publication, does not address state or local tax or the alternative minimum tax, and is subject to change, possibly with retroactive effect. The deductibility of investment interest and related amounts depends on, among other things, whether a taxpayer itemizes deductions and the taxpayer's net investment income, and other limitations may apply. Investors should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve substantial risks, including, without limitation, the risks of leverage, short selling (including the potential for losses that are not limited in amount, recall of borrowed securities, and short squeezes), financing and borrowing costs, model risk, and returns that may differ materially from those of any benchmark. Tax-loss harvesting defers rather than eliminates tax. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Further information about NinePointTwo, including its fees and conflicts of interest, is set forth in its Form ADV Part 2A. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.