NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Deferred Gains

What Eventually Happens to Deferred Gains

The five ways a deferred gain ends under current federal law.

A tax-aware long/short account trades on return forecasts. Gains build in its long positions while losses are realized elsewhere in the book. The tax on those gains is deferred.

Deferral moves the tax to a later date. It does not remove the tax. Under current federal law a deferred gain ends in one of five ways.

How a deferred gain ends under current law

Tax treatment of each ending under current law

A deferred gain

  1. A sale during life

    The gain is realized in the year of sale. Available losses can defer the tax.

    Taxed when sold
  2. A move to long-only

    The short book closes and the long holdings stay in the account. Their embedded gains remain deferred.

    Deferral continues
  3. A bequest

    Long positions generally receive a new basis equal to their value at death.

    New basis at death
  4. A charitable gift

    The charity can sell without capital gains tax. Lots held over a year are generally deductible at fair market value.

    No capital gains tax on the charity's sale
  5. A gift to family

    The recipient generally takes the donor's basis. The gain moves with the shares.

    Gain passes to the recipient

Illustration of general federal rules as currently written. Congress can change them. Each ending depends on the investor's own circumstances and estate plan.

The value of deferral

A deferred gain keeps compounding inside the portfolio. The tax that would have been paid stays invested until the gain is realized. Deferral can have value even when the gain is later taxed in full.

Part of the deferred gain is the pre-tax return the book has earned. Part is the lower basis that follows realized losses. None of the five endings is a reason to hold the strategy. The expected pre-tax return has to justify the account first.

A move to long-only

An investor can stop the long/short strategy without liquidating the account. The short book is closed and the long holdings move toward a long-only index portfolio. The gains embedded in those holdings stay deferred until the positions are sold. The transition can realize some gains, and available losses can defer them.

The basis adjustment at death

Under Section 1014 of the Internal Revenue Code, property acquired from a decedent generally takes a basis equal to its fair market value at the date of death. The heir can sell soon afterward and realize little or no gain. The accumulated gain on those holdings is never subject to income tax. Inherited property is treated as held more than one year. A later gain or loss is long-term.

A long position trading below cost at death takes the lower value as its basis. The unrealized loss cannot be used. In community property states, both halves of community property can receive the new basis when the conditions of the statute are met.

The account's value is included in the gross estate regardless of its income tax basis.

The step-up is current law. Treasury budget proposals in recent years have called for treating transfers at death as realization events, with exclusions and deferral options. No such proposal has been enacted. Congress can revise the rule. A plan that relies on it carries that risk.

Loss carryovers at death

Realized losses that an investor has not used carry forward from year to year during life. They do not pass to heirs. A decedent's capital losses, including carryovers, can be used only on the final income tax return. The estate cannot deduct any amount left unused. A surviving spouse filing a final joint return can use them on that return. Afterward the survivor generally keeps only the share of any carryover attributable to their own losses.

Carryforwards matter in planning for older investors. A loss has value only when there are gains to use it against. A shorter investment horizon may favor realizing gains while carryforwards remain. Any such change is made within the investment program. A trade made only to use losses has no expected return behind it and conflicts with the program's purpose.

Gifts to charity

A public charity that receives appreciated stock can sell the shares without capital gains tax. The donor can generally deduct the shares' fair market value for lots held more than one year. Donor-advised funds are public charities for this purpose. The donor needs a written acknowledgment from the sponsor.

A long/short account holds many lots for less than a year. The deduction for a lot held one year or less is generally limited to the donor's cost basis. Appreciated lots held more than one year are usually the ones to give.

Gifts of long-term appreciated property to public charities, including donor-advised funds, are generally deductible up to 30% of the donor's adjusted gross income in a year. Gifts to private non-operating foundations face a 20% limit. Their deduction is generally limited to basis, with an exception for qualified appreciated stock, such as listed shares. Amounts above the limits carry forward for up to five years. Beginning in 2026, itemized charitable deductions are allowed only above 0.5% of adjusted gross income.

Only long positions can be given. A gift removes those shares from the long book. The manager then rebalances the account to its target exposure. New positions are opened at current prices with no embedded gain.

Gifts to family

A lifetime gift to a family member does not reset basis. The recipient generally takes the donor's basis, and the embedded gain moves with the shares. For shares worth less than the donor's basis at the time of the gift, the recipient's basis for computing a loss is the lower market value.

Common questions

Does a tax-aware long/short account eliminate capital gains tax?

No. The strategy generally defers tax. Gains build in long positions while the long/short book seeks pre-tax alpha and realizes losses. Under current law some deferred gains are never taxed as income, through the basis adjustment at death or a gift of appreciated stock to charity.

Do inherited stocks receive a stepped-up basis?

Under current federal law, property acquired from a decedent generally takes its fair market value at death as its basis. Long positions trading below cost take the lower value.

What happens to capital loss carryovers when an investor dies?

They can be used only on the decedent's final income tax return. The estate cannot deduct them. A surviving spouse generally keeps only the share attributable to their own losses.

Can appreciated shares from a long/short account be given to a donor-advised fund?

Yes. Long positions can be transferred to a donor-advised fund sponsor. Lots held more than one year are generally deductible at fair market value, up to 30% of adjusted gross income. Lots held one year or less are generally deductible only up to their cost basis.

Will the step-up in basis always be available?

It is current federal law. Treasury budget proposals in recent years have called for changing it, and Congress can revise it.

More on tax-aware long/short

Leaving the strategy

What happens to deferred gains when an investor lowers leverage, moves to direct indexing, or transfers the account.

Read the explainer

Tax time

The longer Form 1099, short-sale holding periods, investment interest and the records a tax preparer needs.

Read the explainer

The whitepaper

NinePointTwo's long-form research on how tax-aware long/short works, where the benefit comes from, and its risks.

Read the whitepaper

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC for general educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, legal, estate planning or accounting advice, or as an offer or solicitation with respect to any security or strategy. It contains no hypothetical, simulated or actual performance information. The federal tax rules summarized herein are general in nature, are stated as understood at the date of publication, omit conditions and exceptions that may apply, do not address state, local or estate taxes in detail, and are subject to change, possibly with retroactive effect. Each investor should consult a qualified tax professional and estate planning attorney regarding their own circumstances. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve leverage and short selling, which can magnify losses, including losses in excess of the amount initially invested in a given position, and involve financing, borrowing and trading costs, margin calls and benchmark deviation. There can be no assurance that any strategy will achieve its objectives or generate pre-tax alpha, and an investor may lose money. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.