NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Cost of Shorting

What It Costs to Short a Stock

The costs a long/short book's pre-tax alpha has to cover.

Cash flows paid and received by a long/short book

Paid

Received

Short book

Borrow fee

Paid to the lender of the shares sold short

Long extension

Margin interest

Charged on money borrowed for the long extension

Short book

Short rebate

Interest credited on short sale proceeds

Short book

Payments in lieu

Paid to the lender when a shorted stock pays a dividend

Both sides

Trading costs

Commissions, spreads and market impact

Long book

Dividends on longs

Received on the long positions the account holds

Illustration of the cash flows described on this page. Amounts vary by stock, by custodian and over time. None are shown.

Costs and expected return

A tax-aware long/short account seeks pre-tax alpha and diversification with longs in the stocks its models rate highest and shorts in those they rate lowest. The strategy costs more to run than an index fund.

The account borrows shares to short, borrows money to hold more than 100% long, and trades more often. Those costs reduce the pre-tax return before any tax benefit is counted. A strategy whose alpha does not cover them trails its benchmark before tax. Rates vary by broker, by stock and over time.

The costs and credits of a long/short book

ItemDescriptionDriver
Borrow feePaid to the lender of the shares sold shortSupply of and demand for each stock's shares
Short rebateInterest credited on short sale proceedsThe custodian's credit rate
Margin interestCharged on money borrowed for the long extensionThe debit rate and the size of the extension
Payments in lieuPaid to the lender when a shorted stock pays a dividendDividend yields on the short side
Trading costsCommissions, spreads and market impactTurnover and trade size relative to volume

Borrow fees and the short rebate

A short sale starts with a share loan. Regulation SHO Rule 203(b) requires the broker to borrow the stock, or to have reasonable grounds to believe it can be borrowed, before accepting the order. The shares usually come from the broker's inventory, from other customers' margin accounts or from institutional lenders.

The lender charges a borrow fee, quoted as an annual rate on the value of the shares. The cash from the short sale stays in the account as collateral. The broker credits interest on it, often called the short rebate. The net cost of a short is roughly the borrow fee less that interest. A borrow fee above the interest credited produces a negative rebate.

General collateral and hard-to-borrow stocks

Borrow fees are set by supply and demand in the securities lending market. Most large, widely held stocks have ample lendable supply and modest demand from short sellers. These stocks are called general collateral. Their fees are at the low end of the range.

A minority of stocks are hard to borrow. Lendable supply is thin, short-seller demand is heavy, or both. Their fees can be far higher than general collateral rates, and they can change daily. Hard-to-borrow stocks also tend to carry more recall risk and more squeeze risk. A short in one of them can be expensive to hold and can be closed early by a recall.

The borrow fee is part of the decision to short a stock. A low forecast for a stock that costs little to borrow can justify a short. The same forecast for a hard-to-borrow stock may not cover the fee.

Financing the long extension

In a 130/30 account the short sale proceeds broadly fund the extra 30% of longs. The broker charges margin interest on any debit. Financing cost depends on the spread between the rate charged on the debit and the rate credited on short proceeds, plus borrow fees. That spread matters more than the level of interest rates because the account pays and receives interest at the same time. Custodians net these balances differently, and the exact mechanics depend on the account agreement.

Financing cost rises with the extension. A 300/200 account carries more than six times the short book of a 130/30 account. Margin interest is generally treated as investment interest under Internal Revenue Code section 163(d). The deduction requires itemizing and is limited to net investment income. Any excess carries forward. The treatment depends on each investor's tax situation and can change with tax law.

Dividends on short positions

The lender of a share keeps the economic right to its dividends. When a shorted stock pays a dividend, the short seller pays the lender an equal amount, called a payment in lieu of a dividend. In a long/short book the longs receive dividends and the shorts pay them. The net cash flow depends on the dividend yields on each side.

The tax treatment of these payments depends on how long the short stays open. Under Internal Revenue Code section 263(h), a payment on a short closed within 45 days is not deductible. An exception to the 45-day rule allows a deduction up to the interest the account earned on that short's collateral. The disallowed amount is added instead to the basis of the stock used to close the short. For an extraordinary dividend the period is one year. IRS Publication 550 says a payment on a short held open longer is generally deductible as investment interest. The same itemizing requirement and net investment income limit apply. A manager that trades often can have a meaningful share of payments fall inside the 45-day window. Investors should confirm their own treatment with a tax professional.

Costs in portfolio construction

An alpha model trades when its forecasts change enough to justify the cost. Turnover is far higher than in an index portfolio. Each trade carries commissions, the bid-ask spread and market impact, which is the price movement caused by the trade. Market impact grows with trade size relative to a stock's daily volume.

Costs are controlled before a trade is made. The optimizer generally sets each position by weighing the model's expected return against the expected cost of holding it. That cost includes estimated borrow fees for shorts, financing for the extension and the expected cost of trading. A trade is made only where the forecast, net of those costs, justifies the added risk. Liquidity limits keep positions small enough to trade without moving prices far.

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, applies the same cost discipline to its tax process. A realized loss is weighed alongside expected return, risk and cost.

Common questions

What does it cost to short a stock?

The short seller pays a borrow fee to the lender of the shares and receives interest on the cash proceeds, often called the rebate. The net cost is roughly the fee less the rebate. The short seller also pays the lender an amount equal to any dividends on the borrowed shares.

What is the difference between general collateral and hard-to-borrow stocks?

General collateral stocks have ample lendable supply and low borrow fees. Hard-to-borrow stocks have thin supply or heavy short-seller demand. Their fees are higher, can change daily, and their loans are more likely to be recalled.

Are payments in lieu of dividends deductible?

A payment on a short closed within 45 days is not deductible under Internal Revenue Code section 263(h) and is added to the basis of the stock used to close the short. The exception is a deduction up to the interest earned on that short's collateral. Payments on shorts held longer are generally deductible as investment interest for investors who itemize, within the net investment income limit. Investors should confirm their treatment with a tax professional.

Why do these costs matter for tax-aware long/short?

Borrow, financing, dividend and trading costs reduce the pre-tax return before any tax benefit applies. A tax-aware long/short strategy needs pre-tax alpha large enough to cover them.

How does a quantitative manager control shorting costs?

The manager generally estimates borrow, financing and trading costs for each position and includes them in portfolio construction. A position is then held only where its expected return justifies its cost and risk.

More on tax-aware long/short

Margin, squeezes and recalls

Three risks of borrowing in a long/short account and the portfolio construction that limits them.

Read the explainer

Tax time

The longer Form 1099, short-sale holding periods, investment interest and the records a tax preparer needs.

Read the explainer

Choosing a leverage level

How 130/30 through 300/200 differ in alpha capacity, tracking error, cost and margin.

Read the explainer

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided for educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax or legal advice, or as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment strategy. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve the use of leverage and short selling. Losses on short positions are not limited to the amount invested, and an account using leverage may lose more than the capital committed to it. Financing, borrow, dividend and trading costs are ongoing, vary by custodian and security, may change without notice and reduce returns. Margin approval is required, and a broker may demand additional collateral or liquidate positions at unfavorable prices. The tax treatment of margin interest and payments in lieu of dividends depends on individual circumstances, including whether a taxpayer itemizes deductions and the amount of net investment income, and is subject to change. Investors should confirm their situation with a qualified tax professional. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.