NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Tracking Error

How a Risk Model Governs Tracking Error

How the tracking-error level is set for each investor and where the deviation comes from.

Tracking error measures how far an account's return deviates from its benchmark. Every active position in a tax-aware long/short account adds to it. The positions are held for pre-tax alpha and diversification, and some deviation is intended. The risk model in Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, governs the amount and the type of deviation.

The tracking-error budget sets the range of deviation from the benchmark
  • Benchmark
  • The account
  • Lower budget
  • Higher budget

Hypothetical illustration. The paths are drawn for illustration and are not data. They do not represent a projection or any NinePointTwo strategy. An account can finish above or below its benchmark.

Tracking error and the information ratio

Active return is the portfolio's return minus the benchmark's return over the same period. Tracking error is the standard deviation of that difference, usually stated as an annual figure. It describes the typical size of the gap in either direction. A portfolio can carry high tracking error and beat its benchmark, or carry low tracking error and trail it.

The information ratio is active return divided by tracking error. It measures the excess return a manager earns per unit of tracking error.

Leverage sets the size of the long/short extension. A 130/30 account has 160% gross exposure. A 300/200 account has 500%. More gross exposure lets the models act on more of their views and generally means more tracking error.

Compensated and uncompensated deviation

Any tax-managed equity portfolio deviates from its index. A portfolio cannot realize losses while holding the index exactly. Portfolios differ in whether that deviation carries an expected return.

In direct indexing the deviation is a side effect. The wash sale rule disallows a loss when substantially identical stock is bought within 30 days before or after the sale. The manager buys similar stocks in place of those sold. The resulting drift is uncompensated tracking error.

A long/short book built on alpha models deviates by design. That is compensated tracking error, which is risk that carries an expected return. The compensation is expected and not assured. The models can be wrong for long periods, and the investor bears that risk.

A report shows both kinds as one tracking-error number. The number does not show which kind an account holds.

Compensated and uncompensated tracking error

A long/short book's active positions

Each position is a return forecast

The deviation is intended

It carries an expected return, which can be wrong for long stretches

It stays within a budget set for each investor

Direct indexing drift

A side effect of selling losers and buying substitutes

It moves the portfolio in no particular direction

It carries no return forecast

Managers generally try to keep it small

The risk model

A forecast ranks stocks. It does not account for the sector, size or volatility exposures those stocks carry. The highest-ranked stocks may lean toward one sector, toward small companies or toward stocks that move more than the market. Uncontrolled, those tilts add deviation the forecasts did not intend.

A factor risk model separates a stock's movements into shared and specific parts. The shared parts are exposures to the market, to industries and sectors, and to style factors such as size, value, momentum and volatility. The specific part is what remains after those are removed. The model estimates how each factor tends to move and how the factors move together. From those estimates it can project the tracking error of any proposed portfolio before a trade is placed.

NinePointTwo builds and runs this risk model in-house. Prism tax-aware long/short runs on the same alpha models as NinePointTwo's tax-agnostic long/short equity strategies. In a tax-aware account the risk model holds market exposure close to the benchmark. It limits sector and industry tilts the forecasts do not call for. It limits the size of any single position. The remaining deviation is concentrated where the models have a view.

No risk model is exact. Its estimates come from history, and correlations shift in stressed markets. Realized tracking error can run above or below the level the model projects.

Four inputs weighed at once

  • Expected alpha

    The return models' forecast for each stock, long and short.

  • Risk

    Measured by the risk model against the account's tracking-error budget.

  • Transaction cost

    Market impact, spreads and the cost of borrowing stock to short.

  • Tax

    A realized loss has value to a taxable investor. A realized gain has a cost, which is higher for short-term gains.

The optimization

The optimizer trades only where the forecast, net of trading cost and tax cost, justifies the added risk. A stock with a strong forecast may be held at a smaller weight when buying more would require selling an appreciated lot. A losing position may be sold sooner when the loss has value and the forecast has weakened. Tax considerations inform these decisions within the limits the return model sets. The forecast remains the reason a position is held.

Federal tax law asks whether a transaction has economic substance. The transaction must change the taxpayer's economic position in a meaningful way apart from federal income tax effects, and the taxpayer must have a substantial purpose apart from those effects (IRC section 7701(o)). A long/short book managed for expected return is designed to change the investor's economic position.

Setting the level for each investor

A tracking-error level near zero removes the active positions that are the source of pre-tax alpha. It also removes most loss realization, which comes from a book that continues to trade on its forecasts. The costs of leverage remain with little expected return to cover them.

A larger budget lets the models act on more of their views. It may raise the potential for pre-tax alpha and realized losses. It also raises the chance of returns that differ widely from the benchmark in either direction, and it adds financing and borrowing costs. Pre-tax alpha has to cover those costs.

NinePointTwo sets leverage, tracking error and benchmark for each client, from 130/30 to 300/200. The choice reflects the investor's embedded gains, tolerance for deviating from the market, time horizon and other holdings. A founder reducing a concentrated, low-basis position through Prism Diversify faces a different trade-off from an investor adding Prism Enhance as an overlay to an existing portfolio. The calibration is reviewed as circumstances change.

The risk model allocates the budget to forecasts. Three questions apply to any manager.

  • Where does the account's tracking error come from?
  • How much of it does the manager expect to carry a return?
  • How has the risk model kept unintended sector and factor bets out of the book over time?

Common questions

What is tracking error?

Tracking error is the standard deviation of the difference between a portfolio's return and its benchmark's return. It is usually stated as an annual figure. It measures the typical size of the gap between the two, without regard to direction.

What is the difference between compensated and uncompensated tracking error?

Compensated tracking error comes from positions that carry a return forecast, such as the long and short positions an alpha model selects. Uncompensated tracking error is drift with no expected return, such as the deviation direct indexing accumulates from replacing harvested stocks. Both appear as one number on a report.

How does a risk model control tracking error in a tax-aware long/short account?

A factor risk model estimates how a portfolio's exposures to the market, sectors and style factors are likely to move. The optimizer uses those estimates to keep projected tracking error within the account's budget. It also limits sector, factor and single-stock bets the return forecasts do not call for.

Why not keep tracking error as low as possible?

In a long/short account, low tracking error means few active positions. Those positions are the source of potential pre-tax alpha and of continued loss realization. A budget near zero leaves leverage and its costs with little expected return to cover them.

Who sets the tracking-error budget for Prism tax-aware long/short?

NinePointTwo sets leverage, tracking error and benchmark for each client. The choice reflects embedded gains, risk tolerance, time horizon and the rest of the client's holdings, and it is revisited as those change.

More on tax-aware long/short

Choosing a leverage level

How 130/30 through 300/200 differ in alpha capacity, tracking error, cost and margin.

Read the explainer

Versus direct indexing

How tax-aware long/short and direct indexing realize losses, and why harvesting in a long-only portfolio slows.

Compare with direct indexing

The cost of shorting

Borrow fees, financing, payments in lieu of dividends and trading costs, which pre-tax alpha has to cover.

Read the explainer

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC ("NinePointTwo") for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice, or as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment service. It contains no actual, hypothetical, simulated, or back-tested performance information. Descriptions of portfolio construction, risk models, and optimization are general in nature, may change without notice, and are not to be regarded as a representation or warranty, express or implied, that any strategy will achieve its objectives or will control risk as intended. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve substantial risks, including, without limitation, the risks of leverage, short selling (including the potential for losses that are not limited in amount, recall of borrowed securities, and short squeezes), financing and borrowing costs, model risk, and returns that may differ materially from those of any benchmark. Tax-loss harvesting defers rather than eliminates tax, and its effectiveness depends on individual circumstances. Tax law is subject to change. Investors should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Further information about NinePointTwo, including its fees and conflicts of interest, is set forth in its Form ADV Part 2A. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.