NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Risks

Margin Calls, Short Squeezes and Recalls

Three risks that follow from borrowing and the portfolio construction that limits them.

The margin cushion and a margin call

In ordinary conditions

After longs fall while shorts rise

Hypothetical illustration. Levels are not to scale. The broker sets the maintenance requirement and can raise it without advance notice.

Why the account borrows

A tax-aware long/short account shorts the stocks its models rate lowest and holds extra longs in those they rate highest. The book is managed for pre-tax alpha and diversification. The tax benefits arise from its trading.

A short position requires borrowing shares and selling them. Holding more than 100% long requires borrowing money. Both kinds of borrowing carry risks a long-only index portfolio does not. Margin calls, short squeezes and recalls of borrowed shares are the three main ones. Each can force a trade the manager did not choose.

Margin calls

A long/short account is a margin account. In a standard margin account, Federal Reserve Regulation T sets the margin needed to open positions. A long purchase needs 50% of its value in margin. A short sale needs 150% of the short's value, which is the sale proceeds plus another 50%. Those requirements support a configuration of about 150/50. Higher configurations are margined under a risk-based method applied by the broker.

After positions are open, FINRA Rule 4210 sets minimum maintenance requirements. In a standard margin account the minimum for long stock is 25% of market value. For short stock priced at $5 or more it is the greater of $5 per share or 30% of market value. Brokers may set higher "house" requirements. FINRA's required margin disclosure states that a firm can raise those house requirements at any time without advance notice. It also states that a firm can sell positions without contacting the customer, and that the customer chooses neither the timing nor which securities are sold.

A margin call occurs when account equity falls below the requirement. In a broad market decline the longs lose value and the shorts gain. Net market exposure stays near that of an index portfolio. The larger risk to margin is a spread move against the book, in which the longs fall while the shorts rise. That can happen when market leadership reverses quickly. A broker can also raise its house requirements, which can leave a compliant account with a deficiency overnight.

Short squeezes

A short position loses money when its stock rises. The loss has no fixed limit. A short squeeze is the extreme case. When a heavily shorted stock rises sharply, some short sellers buy shares to close their positions. That buying can push the price higher, which leads more short sellers to buy.

The loss from a squeeze depends on position size. A short that is a large share of an account can trigger a margin call by itself. The same price move in a small position is a modest loss in a diversified book.

Recalls of borrowed shares

Every short sale depends on a share loan. Regulation SHO Rule 203(b) requires the broker to borrow the stock, or have reasonable grounds to believe it can be borrowed, before accepting the short sale. The lender keeps the right to end the loan, generally on short notice under standard securities lending agreements. A lender may recall shares to sell them, to vote them, or because it has stopped lending.

The broker usually replaces recalled shares from another lender. When no replacement is available, the short is bought back, sometimes through a buy-in at the prevailing price. Recalls tend to occur in the same stocks as squeezes. Loans on stocks in heavy demand from short sellers are the most often recalled or not renewed. A forced close also realizes the gain or loss in the position at that time.

Controls in portfolio construction

Most controls are set in portfolio construction. Each limits the share of the account exposed to a single stock or event.

  • Diversified books

    A model-driven book holds many positions on each side. A squeeze or recall in one name affects a small share of capital.

  • Position limits

    Limits on any single long or short are set in the same optimization that weighs the alpha forecasts. No single stock is allowed to dominate results or margin.

  • Liquidity screens

    The optimizer ties each position's size to the stock's trading volume. Positions stay small enough to exit without moving the price far.

  • Borrow screens

    Expected borrow cost and lendable supply enter the optimization for every short. Names with high borrow fees, scarce lendable supply or crowded short interest are avoided or sized down. Those are the names most exposed to squeezes and recalls.

  • The risk model

    A risk model measures exposure to the market, industries and style factors such as value and momentum. Constraining those exposures limits the spread moves that drive margin calls in long/short books.

  • Leverage sized to collateral

    Leverage set with a cushion above the maintenance requirement leaves time to reduce positions in an orderly way. Daily margin monitoring shows when the cushion is shrinking. Cash or other holdings added to the account increase it.

NinePointTwo builds these controls into Prism, its tax-aware long/short strategy, with a risk model it runs in-house.

The limits of diversification

The controls reduce the size of individual events but do not remove the risks. Diversification is less effective when many positions move together, and quantitative books are exposed to that kind of move. Sharp factor reversals and crowded unwinds, in which many managers exit similar positions at once, can produce losses across hundreds of names on the same day. Leverage magnifies those losses. An account can lose more than the capital invested, and a broker can liquidate positions at unfavorable prices to meet a margin call.

NinePointTwo's view is that these risks are worth bearing only for the expected pre-tax return. Realized losses and deferred gains are not by themselves a reason to carry leverage and short positions.

Common questions

What usually causes a margin call in a long/short account?

A margin call occurs when account equity falls below the broker's maintenance requirement. In a long/short account that usually comes from the longs falling while the shorts rise, or from a broker raising its house requirements. The risk model limits the spread exposures behind most such moves. NinePointTwo also sizes each account's leverage to its collateral and monitors margin daily.

Can an investor lose more than the amount invested?

Yes. Losses on a short position are not capped, and leverage magnifies losses. A broker may also sell positions at unfavorable prices to meet a margin call.

What is a short squeeze?

A short squeeze is a rapid rise in a heavily shorted stock, driven partly by short sellers buying shares to close their positions. A diversified book with small position sizes limits the effect of any one squeeze, though it does not prevent losses.

What happens when borrowed shares are recalled?

The broker generally seeks replacement shares from another lender. When none are available, the short position is bought back at the prevailing price. That can realize a gain or loss at a time the manager did not choose.

How does a quantitative manager reduce these risks?

The main tools are many small positions, caps on position size, liquidity and borrow screens, a risk model that limits factor and industry exposure, and leverage sized to the account's collateral.

More on tax-aware long/short

The cost of shorting

Borrow fees, financing, payments in lieu of dividends and trading costs, which pre-tax alpha has to cover.

Read the explainer

Choosing a leverage level

How 130/30 through 300/200 differ in alpha capacity, tracking error, cost and margin.

Read the explainer

Tracking error and the risk model

Compensated and uncompensated tracking error, and how one optimization weighs alpha, risk, cost and tax.

Read the explainer

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This material is provided for educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax or legal advice, or as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment strategy. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve the use of leverage and short selling. Losses on short positions are not limited to the amount invested, and an account using leverage may lose more than the capital committed to it. Margin approval is required, and a broker may demand additional collateral or liquidate positions at unfavorable prices, without notice. Borrowed securities may be recalled, and financing and borrow costs may change. Risk controls, including those described herein, may not prevent losses. The tax consequences of any strategy depend on individual circumstances and are subject to change. Investors should confirm their situation with a qualified tax professional. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.