Versus direct indexing
How tax-aware long/short and direct indexing realize losses, and why harvesting in a long-only portfolio slows.
Compare with direct indexingWhat happens to deferred gains when an investor lowers leverage, stops the strategy or moves the account.
A tax-aware long/short account is managed for pre-tax alpha and diversification. Deferred gains build up in the account as it trades. A gain is taxed only when the position holding it is sold or closed.
Closing the whole account at once realizes every embedded gain and loss in that tax year. A gradual exit lets realized losses defer gains as positions are closed.
200/100
Starting point
150/50
First reduction
130/30
Second reduction
Long-only
Short book closed
Illustration of one possible path, per $100 of capital. Each step closes positions on both sides. Lot selection by the manager determines the gains and losses realized.
Part of each side closes. The gains and losses realized are those in the lots the manager selects. A smaller book carries less active risk.
The short book closes and the lowest-gain longs are sold. The remaining holdings form a long-only index portfolio. Realized losses can defer the gains.
Long positions move to another firm with their basis and holding periods. Shorts and margin balances may have to be settled first.
The embedded gain in an account has three sources. The first is the gain in any stock contributed at funding. The second is the pre-tax return the account has earned. The third is the lower cost basis that follows a realized loss. The replacement position is bought at a lower price than the one sold.
Realized losses an investor has not yet used carry forward to later years. They keep their short-term or long-term character. For individuals a carryforward continues during the investor's life until used. Up to $3,000 a year of net capital loss can be applied against ordinary income. Carryforwards can defer gains realized at exit.
Moving a 200/100 account to 150/50 closes a quarter of the long book and half of the short book. The manager selects the lots. Long lots near or below cost realize little gain or a loss. Shorts trading above their sale price realize a loss when covered. Positions the models rate poorly are also candidates.
Gains and losses on closing a short sale are generally short-term, regardless of how long the short was open. Short-term losses are applied first against short-term gains.
A smaller long/short book carries less active risk and less exposure to the alpha models. Expected pre-tax alpha and the pace of loss realization generally decline with it.
An investor can stop the strategy in two ways. A full liquidation realizes all embedded gains and losses in the year of sale. A transition closes the short book and moves the long holdings toward a long-only index portfolio in the same account. NinePointTwo prefers the transition.
A 200/100 account holds twice the long positions of a long-only portfolio. Covering the shorts and repaying the margin balance requires selling part of the long book. The manager sells the long lots with the least gain. Losses from covering shorts and from carryforwards can defer the gains realized. The remaining holdings form a diversified, index-like portfolio. Their embedded gains stay deferred.
The net gain realized in a transition depends on the embedded gain, the losses available and market moves along the way. A transition can span more than one tax year. A long-only account no longer seeks pre-tax alpha from a long/short book and has less capacity to realize new losses.
Long positions can generally transfer between brokerage accounts in kind. A transfer between two accounts of the same owner is not a sale and realizes no gain. The delivering broker reports each covered lot's adjusted basis and acquisition date to the receiving broker. Older lots are often not covered, and the investor supplies their basis from personal records. The embedded gain moves with the shares.
Short positions and margin balances may have to be closed or settled as part of the transfer. The receiving firm sets the requirements. Covering the shorts realizes their gains and losses in that tax year.
Two tax rules apply across an investor's accounts during a move. The wash sale rule disallows a loss when substantially identical stock is bought within 30 days before or after the sale. The rule covers all of an investor's accounts, including IRAs. A short position in one account against an appreciated holding of the same stock in another can be treated as a constructive sale. The manager sequences the exit trades across accounts under both rules.
Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, has no lockup. A client can lower leverage or close the account at any time. The exit plan is set when the account opens, along with leverage, tracking error and benchmark. The plan determines how deferred gains are later realized, transferred or held.
The gains stay embedded in the positions until those positions are sold or closed. Liquidating the account at once realizes all of them in that tax year. A gradual exit lets realized losses and any loss carryforward defer gains as positions are closed.
Yes. Lowering leverage closes part of the long book and part of the short book. The manager can select lots with losses or little gain. Lower leverage also reduces active risk and expected pre-tax alpha.
The manager covers the short book and sells the long lots with the least gain to repay the margin balance. Realized losses and carryforwards can defer those gains. The transition can span more than one tax year. NinePointTwo prefers this exit from Prism tax-aware long/short. The result depends on embedded gains, available losses and market conditions.
Long positions transferred in kind keep their adjusted basis and original acquisition dates. The delivering broker reports both to the receiving broker for covered lots. Short positions and margin balances may have to be closed or settled first.
No. The account can be reduced or closed at any time. Closing positions realizes whatever gains or losses are embedded in them.
How tax-aware long/short and direct indexing realize losses, and why harvesting in a long-only portfolio slows.
Compare with direct indexingHow a deferred gain ends in a sale, a move to long-only, a bequest, a charitable gift or a gift to family.
Read the explainerHow 130/30 through 300/200 differ in alpha capacity, tracking error, cost and margin.
Read the explainerTell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.
This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, legal or accounting advice, or as an offer or solicitation with respect to any security or strategy. It contains no hypothetical, simulated or actual performance information. The tax treatment described herein is general in nature, is based on federal law as understood at the date of publication, is subject to change, possibly with retroactive effect, and may not apply to any particular investor. Each investor should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve leverage and short selling, which can magnify losses, including losses in excess of the amount initially invested in a given position, and involve financing, borrowing and trading costs, margin calls and benchmark deviation. There can be no assurance that any strategy will achieve its objectives, generate pre-tax alpha, or realize losses in any amount, and an investor may lose money. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.