NinePointTwo CapitalNinePointTwo CapitalClient Portal
  1. Tax-Aware
  2. Versus Exchange Funds

Tax-Aware Long/Short vs. Exchange Funds

Both are ways to diversify a concentrated, low-basis stock position without paying the full capital gains tax at the outset.They differ in where the return comes from, how fast the position is diversified, and what the investor gives up for the deferral.

How the two structures differ

An exchange fund is a limited partnership. An investor contributes appreciated stock for partnership units and holds a share of the whole pool from the first day. The exchange generally does not trigger tax, and the investor commits to a holding period of typically seven years.

A tax-aware long/short account keeps the position in a separately managed account in the investor's name. A long/short book selected on return forecasts is funded alongside it and seeks pre-tax alpha and diversification. The book also realizes losses. The stock is sold in stages as those losses defer the gains.

The exchange fund diversifies at contribution. It requires a long lockup and gives the investor no control over the holdings. The long/short account diversifies over time with daily liquidity and full control. It requires capital or borrowing capacity alongside the position and carries leverage and short-selling risk.

Both defer the tax. The original basis carries forward in each, and the gain stays embedded until the shares are sold.

Where each structure's return comes from

An exchange fund and a tax-aware long/short account both defer the gain. The two differ in what the investor owns while the gain is deferred.

The long/short account adds an active return source. The exchange fund holds a pool of contributed stocks.

Return forecasts behind the book

The long/short book holds the stocks its models rate highest and shorts those they rate lowest. Its deviation from the benchmark is intended, and it seeks pre-tax alpha with low correlation to the market.

A pool built from contributions

An exchange fund's portfolio is assembled from the stocks its investors contribute, within the sponsor's limits on any one company. Its return is the return of that pool. The holdings reflect what other investors contributed.

Alpha and the tax benefit together

In a long/short account, alpha grows the base that losses are drawn from. Keeping leverage on target also opens new positions with no embedded gain. The pre-tax return and the tax benefit can reinforce each other over time.

How each structure invests and diversifies

Tax-aware long/short

Source of return

A diversified portfolio plus a long/short alpha book

Accepts

Any position, held in the investor's own account

Diversification

Gradual, as realized losses defer gains on a staged sale

Liquidity

Daily, no lockup

The concentrated stock cannot produce a loss while it carries a large gain. The losses come from a long/short book funded with capital alongside the position. Short positions can realize losses when their stocks rise, and long positions when theirs fall.

As losses accumulate, the investor sells the stock in stages and applies the losses against the gains. The proceeds move into a diversified portfolio in the same account. The pace depends on the position's size relative to the capital funding the program and on market conditions.

The account stays in the investor's name, and every holding is visible.

Exchange fund

Source of return

The pool of contributed stocks and qualifying assets

Accepts

Stocks the sponsor is willing to accept

Diversification

Immediate, across the pool at contribution

Liquidity

Typically seven years

Under Section 721 the exchange generally does not trigger tax. The fund pools positions from many investors alongside qualifying assets, often real estate, that preserve its tax treatment.

The units represent the whole pool from the first day, so the investor no longer carries single-stock risk.

The tax code discourages early exits. An investor who redeems within seven years generally receives their original shares back. After seven years, redemption can be taken as a diversified basket from the pool. The original basis carries into that basket, and the gain stays embedded until those shares are sold.

How Prism tax-aware long/short sells down a position

Prism Diversify is the approach of Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, for a concentrated, low-basis position. The expected path of the sell-down is typically modeled with the client before anything is implemented. The sell-down takes several years, fewer at higher leverage. Neither the pace nor the losses are guaranteed.

Prism runs on the same alpha models as NinePointTwo's tax-agnostic long/short equity strategies. Positions in the long/short book generally follow those forecasts, because the strategy seeks pre-tax alpha. Within the limits of that return model, gains are typically deferred and losses realized.

How the two structures compare

The table compares Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, with a typical exchange fund. Terms vary by sponsor and by account.

Prism Tax-Aware Long/ShortExchange Fund
Source of pre-tax returnThe diversified portfolio plus a long/short alpha overlayThe pooled portfolio's holdings
What you can contributeAny position. There is no eligibility test on the position itself, though the economics depend on its size relative to the capital funding the program.A concentrated position in a stock the fund is willing to accept. Eligibility standards vary by sponsor.
DiversificationGradual, over a sell-down that takes several yearsImmediate, across the pool from the first day
Capital requiredCapital or borrowing capacity alongside the positionNone beyond the contributed stock
Who can investNo accreditation requirement. Accounts generally begin at $1 million, subject to suitability.Accredited investors, and in many cases qualified purchasers. The fund is a private placement, so the standard is set by securities law and by the sponsor.
TimingAny time. The program starts when the investor is ready.Subscription periods set by the sponsor.
What you end up owningA diversified portfolio held directly in the investor's own account, designed around their broader situation.Partnership units, and after seven years a basket of stocks drawn from the pool. The composition reflects what others contributed.
LiquidityDaily liquidity in a separately managed account. The strategy can be scaled back or unwound at any time, though exiting early cuts the tax benefit short.Typically a seven-year holding period. Redeeming early generally returns the original shares and can unwind much of the benefit.
Tax treatmentHarvested losses may defer gains as the position is sold, with deferral showing up as reduced basis in the long/short portfolio. Loss generation depends on market conditions and is not guaranteed.Contribution defers tax and the original basis carries into the redemption basket. The gain stays embedded until those shares are sold.
Control and customizationFull. The investor sees every holding, keeps them in their own account, and sets the pace of the sell-down with the manager.None. The underlying holdings, early-exit treatment, and final basket composition are set by the fund.
CostsAn advisory fee on the account, plus the trading and financing costs of running a long/short portfolio. No pooled vehicle and no placement fee.Ongoing management fees on the pooled vehicle, and in some cases placement fees or early-redemption charges.

Source of pre-tax return

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

The diversified portfolio plus a long/short alpha overlay

Exchange Fund

The pooled portfolio's holdings

What you can contribute

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Any position. There is no eligibility test on the position itself, though the economics depend on its size relative to the capital funding the program.

Exchange Fund

A concentrated position in a stock the fund is willing to accept. Eligibility standards vary by sponsor.

Diversification

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Gradual, over a sell-down that takes several years

Exchange Fund

Immediate, across the pool from the first day

Capital required

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Capital or borrowing capacity alongside the position

Exchange Fund

None beyond the contributed stock

Who can invest

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

No accreditation requirement. Accounts generally begin at $1 million, subject to suitability.

Exchange Fund

Accredited investors, and in many cases qualified purchasers. The fund is a private placement, so the standard is set by securities law and by the sponsor.

Timing

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Any time. The program starts when the investor is ready.

Exchange Fund

Subscription periods set by the sponsor.

What you end up owning

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

A diversified portfolio held directly in the investor's own account, designed around their broader situation.

Exchange Fund

Partnership units, and after seven years a basket of stocks drawn from the pool. The composition reflects what others contributed.

Liquidity

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Daily liquidity in a separately managed account. The strategy can be scaled back or unwound at any time, though exiting early cuts the tax benefit short.

Exchange Fund

Typically a seven-year holding period. Redeeming early generally returns the original shares and can unwind much of the benefit.

Tax treatment

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Harvested losses may defer gains as the position is sold, with deferral showing up as reduced basis in the long/short portfolio. Loss generation depends on market conditions and is not guaranteed.

Exchange Fund

Contribution defers tax and the original basis carries into the redemption basket. The gain stays embedded until those shares are sold.

Control and customization

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

Full. The investor sees every holding, keeps them in their own account, and sets the pace of the sell-down with the manager.

Exchange Fund

None. The underlying holdings, early-exit treatment, and final basket composition are set by the fund.

Costs

Prism Tax-Aware Long/Short

An advisory fee on the account, plus the trading and financing costs of running a long/short portfolio. No pooled vehicle and no placement fee.

Exchange Fund

Ongoing management fees on the pooled vehicle, and in some cases placement fees or early-redemption charges.

The tradeoffs of each structure

  • Time

    An exchange fund diversifies at contribution. A long/short sell-down diversifies over time, and the single-stock risk remains on the shares not yet sold.

  • Liquidity and control

    An exchange fund generally holds the investment for seven years and sets the final basket. A long/short account keeps daily liquidity and every holding in the investor's name.

  • Capital and risk

    A long/short program needs capital or borrowing capacity alongside the position. It carries leverage, short-selling risk, financing costs, and tracking error. Its pre-tax alpha has to cover those costs.

Both structures defer tax. The basis step-up at death and charitable gifts of appreciated stock remain available with either.

Which investors each structure suits

An exchange fund is often the simpler choice for an investor who wants a single transaction and can accept the lockup. A tax-aware long/short account generally suits an investor who wants an active return source, values liquidity and control, and has capital to commit alongside the position.

Tax-aware long/short

  • Investors who value daily liquidity and control of the holdings
  • Capital or borrowing capacity to commit alongside the position
  • Investors who want pre-tax alpha from a long/short book
  • Tolerance for leverage, short selling, and higher tracking error

Exchange fund

  • A genuinely concentrated position to diversify
  • No spare capital to commit alongside the position
  • Comfort with a seven-year holding period
  • One transaction preferred over an ongoing program

The two are not mutually exclusive. Some investors contribute part of a position to an exchange fund and apply a tax-aware long/short program to the remainder. The long/short account's realized losses can also be applied against gains realized elsewhere.

Common questions

What is the difference between an exchange fund and tax-aware long/short?

An exchange fund takes appreciated stock into a limited partnership and diversifies the investor across the pool at contribution, in return for a holding period of typically seven years. A tax-aware long/short account keeps the stock in the investor's own account and sells it down in stages, using losses realized by a long/short book to defer the gains. The long/short account keeps daily liquidity and seeks pre-tax alpha. It also needs capital alongside the position and carries leverage and short-selling risk.

Does an exchange fund seek alpha?

Generally not. An exchange fund's portfolio is built from the stocks its investors contribute, so its return is the return of that pool. A tax-aware long/short account adds a long/short book chosen by return forecasts, which seeks pre-tax alpha alongside the tax benefit. That alpha has to cover the account's higher fees, financing, and trading costs.

Why is contributing stock to an exchange fund generally not taxable?

Under Section 721 of the tax code, contributing property to a partnership in exchange for an interest in it generally does not trigger tax. A separate rule makes the exchange taxable when it diversifies the contributors' interests in a partnership that would be treated as an investment company. Exchange funds hold qualifying assets, often real estate, alongside the contributed stock to preserve the treatment. Whether a specific contribution qualifies depends on the fund's structure and the investor's facts.

What happens if an investor needs to exit an exchange fund early?

Terms vary by fund. Early redemption generally returns the investor's original shares, and some funds return the lesser of the value at contribution or at redemption. Charges may apply, and the diversification benefit largely unwinds. This is the structural price of the tax treatment and applies across sponsors.

How long does a tax-aware long/short sell-down take?

It depends on the size of the position relative to the capital funding the program. Market conditions and the pace of loss generation matter as well, and none of these is guaranteed. The sell-down takes several years, fewer at higher leverage. The expected path is typically modeled with the client before anything is implemented.

Who can invest in an exchange fund?

Exchange funds are private placements, generally open to accredited investors and in many cases only to qualified purchasers. Sponsors also decide which stocks they accept, since each fund limits how much of any one company it holds. A tax-aware long/short account has no accreditation requirement. Prism tax-aware long/short accounts generally begin at $1 million, subject to suitability.

Does either structure eliminate the capital gains tax?

No. Both defer it. An exchange fund carries the original basis into the basket an investor eventually receives. In a long/short program, losses used against the sale are paired with reduced basis elsewhere in the portfolio. Deferral still has value, because the portfolio compounds on a larger base in the meantime. The basis step-up at death and charitable gifts of appreciated stock remain available with either structure.

Can an investor use both?

Yes. Some investors contribute part of a position to an exchange fund and apply a tax-aware long/short program to the remainder. Others use the program's realized losses against gains realized elsewhere.

How do the costs compare?

An exchange fund charges ongoing management fees on the pooled vehicle, and some charge placement fees or early-redemption charges. A tax-aware long/short account pays an advisory fee plus the trading and financing costs of the long/short book. The strategy's pre-tax alpha has to cover them. Fee terms for Prism tax-aware long/short are set out in NinePointTwo's Form ADV.

More on tax-aware long/short

The strategy

How tax-aware long/short works, the configurations from 130/30 to 300/200, and the investors it is designed for.

Read about the strategy

The three approaches

Prism, NinePointTwo's tax-aware long/short strategy, in three approaches for alpha, concentrated stock, and an existing portfolio.

Explore the approaches

The illustration tool

A hypothetical comparison of selling a concentrated position today with deferring the gain through tax-aware long/short.

Model a position

The provider comparison

Tax-aware long/short providers compared on minimums, fees, leverage, custody, and access, with dated sources.

Compare the providers

Versus direct indexing

How tax-aware long/short and direct indexing realize losses, and why harvesting in a long-only portfolio slows.

Compare with direct indexing

Three routes for concentrated stock

Section 351 conversions, exchange funds, and tax-aware long/short accounts compared for low-basis holdings.

Compare the three routes

Request a meeting

Tell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.

This page is a general comparison of two investment structures and is provided for informational purposes only. It describes typical structures rather than any specific exchange fund or sponsor, and terms vary. Nothing herein should be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice, or as an offer of any security. Investing involves substantial risk, including the possible loss of principal. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve unique risks, including short selling and leverage, and may not be suitable for all investors. Both structures defer tax and do not eliminate it. The effectiveness of tax management strategies depends on individual taxpayer circumstances and may vary. Past performance is not indicative of future results. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.