The guide
How tax-aware long/short works, its costs and risks, and how a deferred gain ends.
Read the guideHow investors use a tax-aware long/short account to add a return source alongside existing holdings, diversify a concentrated stock position, and prepare for a large capital gain.
Many wealthy investors hold assets that respond to the same forces. Public equities, private equity, real estate and an operating business all tend to do well when the economy grows and poorly when it contracts. Adding more of any of them adds little diversification.
A long/short book holds the stocks its models rank highest and shorts those they rank lowest. Its return depends on the spread between the two groups. Market direction has much less influence. That return is expected to have a low correlation with the rest of the portfolio.
The account keeps its market exposure. An investor who moves $5 million of index holdings into a 150/50 account holds $7.5 million of long positions and $2.5 million of shorts. Net exposure remains $5 million.
Taxes are one input to each trade. Trading on the forecasts also realizes losses. Gains are deferred where the models allow.
Without pre-tax alpha the investor still pays financing, borrowing and trading costs. The account can also trail its benchmark for long periods.
Existing holdings
Driven largely by economic growth
Long/short book
Driven by the spread between the two groups
Hypothetical illustration. The correlation between the two is not fixed and can rise in stressed markets.
A founder, an early employee or a long-term holder often holds most of their wealth in one stock. The concentration is a risk. The tax on a sale is the obstacle to reducing it. An investor with $10 million of stock and a $1 million basis carries a $9 million gain. Selling it in a high-tax state costs roughly 37% of that gain in combined federal and state tax, or about $3.3 million.
The account reduces the position in stages. The stock transfers in without being sold. A long/short book is funded alongside it with cash or with borrowing against the position. The book realizes losses as it trades. Those losses defer gains on portions of the stock as they are sold. The proceeds go into the diversified portfolio.
The stock's weight falls with each stage. The process takes several years, fewer at higher leverage. Neither its pace nor the size of the losses is assured.
The book does not hedge the stock. Shorting the same shares would generally count as a sale of them. The investor carries the stock's risk until it is sold, along with the leverage and shorting risk of the book.
At funding
First sales
Further sales
Sold down
Hypothetical illustration. Proportions are not to scale. The pace of a sell-down and the size of realized losses are not assured.
Some gains are visible years before they arrive. A company sale, a planned liquidity event and carried interest from a maturing fund are common examples. A founder who expects a $20 million gain on a sale in three years faces about $7.4 million of combined tax at a 37% rate.
Losses realized in the years before the sale carry forward during the investor's life. They can apply in the year the gain is recognized.
Realized losses tend to be largest in an account's first years. An account opened in the year of the sale has less to contribute than one opened earlier.
The capital is invested throughout. It earns the market's return plus or minus the return of the long/short book. An event that is delayed or cancelled leaves the investor with an equity portfolio and unused carryforwards.
Years before the event
The capital is invested for return from the first day.
Each year until then
Losses with no gains to use them against carry forward during the investor's life.
Year of the event
Carryforwards can apply against it. The remainder of the gain is taxed.
Hypothetical illustration of the sequence. The loss realized in any year is not assured, and a tax adviser should review how carryforwards apply.
The account is the same in each use. Positions are selected on return forecasts. The investment case has to hold before any tax effect is counted. The uses can also be combined. A founder may fund an account ahead of a sale and later move a concentrated position into it.
The costs do not change with the purpose. Each use carries a management fee, financing and borrowing costs, tracking error against the benchmark, and the risks of leverage and short selling. Deferred gains remain taxable when they are realized.
Investors generally use it for one of three purposes. Some want an equity return source with a low expected correlation to their other holdings. Some hold a concentrated stock position they want to reduce over time. Others expect a large capital gain and open an account in advance.
No. An account can be funded with cash or with an existing diversified portfolio. Its purpose is then the long/short book's pre-tax return, with tax management as part of the process.
Earlier is generally better. Unused capital losses carry forward, and an account tends to realize more of them in its first years than later. The right timing depends on the size and certainty of the expected gain, which an investor should review with a tax adviser.
Yes. One account can hold a concentrated position, a diversified portfolio and the long/short book together. Leverage and tracking error are set for the investor's whole situation.
How tax-aware long/short works, its costs and risks, and how a deferred gain ends.
Read the guideSection 351 conversions, exchange funds, and tax-aware long/short accounts compared for low-basis holdings.
Compare the three routesA hypothetical comparison of selling a concentrated position today with deferring the gain through tax-aware long/short.
Model a positionTell us which approach interests you and we will follow up to arrange a conversation.
This material is provided by NinePointTwo Capital LLC for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, legal or accounting advice, or as an offer or solicitation with respect to any security or strategy. It contains no hypothetical, simulated or actual performance information. The dollar examples herein are arithmetic illustrations of exposure and of tax at the rates stated, are not based on any investor's circumstances, and do not represent the results of any strategy or account. The tax treatment described herein is general in nature, is based on federal law as understood at the date of publication, is subject to change, possibly with retroactive effect, and may not apply to any particular investor. Each investor should consult a qualified tax professional regarding their own circumstances. Tax-aware long/short strategies involve leverage and short selling, which can magnify losses, including losses in excess of the amount initially invested in a given position, and involve financing, borrowing and trading costs, margin calls and benchmark deviation. The pace of any sell-down and the amount of any realized losses are not guaranteed, there can be no assurance that any strategy will achieve its objectives or generate pre-tax alpha, and an investor may lose money. See our Disclosures page for additional important information.